Home Eat & Drink 13 Best Restaurants to Try in Newton, NJ
Eat & Drink

13 Best Restaurants to Try in Newton, NJ

Share
13 Best Restaurants to Try in Newton
Share

Never miss what is happening in Sussex County

Events, new openings and weekend plans from Newton to Vernon, Sparta to Stanhope. Straight to your inbox, free.

Subscribe free

Looking for where to eat in Newton, NJ? Our team rounded up thirteen open restaurants in and around Newton, the Sussex County seat, from a farm-to-table brunch room, an Irish pub and the town’s oldest pizzeria to Thai Lao, Indian, Mexican, Colombian and Spanish kitchens, a cheese and charcuterie shop, two classic diners, a lakefront tavern and a lakeside dining room on Swartswood Lake. Addresses, phone numbers and hours below come from each restaurant’s own current website.

Most of these spots sit within a short walk of each other on Spring Street and the side streets around the Newton Green, so it is easy to pair a meal with an errand, a show or a stroll downtown. A few carry Newton addresses just outside town and are worth the short drive. Making a day of it? Our guide to things to do in Newton, NJ fills the hours before dinner. Heading south? See our picks for where to eat and drink in Sparta.

Voting is open
Vote for the Best of Sussex County 2026
Think we missed your favorite? Cast your vote for the best restaurants in Sussex County and help crown this year’s winners.

Vote Now

Voting closes November 30, 2026

The Farmer’s Daughter

A dish at The Farmer's Daughter in Newton, NJ
Photo: The Farmer’s Daughter via Google Business Profile.

The Farmer’s Daughter at 161-165 Spring Street pairs a seasonal restaurant with a curated market of local goods, antiques, gifts and gourmet foods. The dining room serves Wednesday through Saturday from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. and 5 to 8 p.m., with last seating at 2 p.m. for lunch and 7 p.m. for dinner, plus Sunday brunch from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. with last seating at 1 p.m. It is closed Monday and Tuesday, and the restaurant notes it is not doing takeout at this time. Reservations are taken at 973-383-0440.

O’Reilly’s Pub and Grill

O'Reilly's Pub and Grill sign and building at 271 Spring Street in Newton, NJ
Photo: O’Reilly’s Pub and Grill via Google Business Profile.

O’Reilly’s Pub and Grill at 271 Spring Street is the late-night pick on this list. The pub opens at 11:30 a.m. seven days a week and serves food until midnight every day. Call 973-383-4091 for takeout or to reserve a table, or order through the online ordering link on the pub’s website.

Poy’s Kitchen Thai Lao Cuisine

Poy's Kitchen mural on the Thai Lao restaurant in Newton, NJ
Photo: Poy’s Kitchen Thai Lao Cuisine via Google Business Profile.

Poy’s Kitchen Thai Lao Cuisine at 240 Spring Street opened in 2022 and cooks traditional Thai and Lao family dishes. It is mostly a takeout kitchen with limited seating, and it is BYOB with party trays available. Hours are Monday 11:30 a.m. to 8 p.m., Tuesday through Friday 11:30 a.m. to 9 p.m., Saturday 12:30 to 9 p.m. and Sunday 12:30 to 8 p.m. Call 973-821-5028.

Indian Masala

Samosas at Indian Masala in Newton, NJ
Photo: Indian Masala via Google Business Profile.

Indian Masala at 214 Spring Street serves authentic Indian food, with online ordering on its website and through its own mobile app. The restaurant lists service until 9 p.m. on Sunday, Monday, Wednesday and Thursday and until 10 p.m. on Friday and Saturday. It is closed Tuesday. Call 862-275-7128.

Mi Rancho Mexican Grill

Papel picado dining room at Mi Rancho Mexican Grill in Newton, NJ
Photo: Mi Rancho Mexican Grill via Google Business Profile.

Mi Rancho Mexican Grill at 195 Spring Street brings a colorful dining room and a menu that includes traditional tacos with cilantro and onion, birria tacos and a birria burrito. Hours are 10 a.m. to 9 p.m. every day except Tuesday, when it is closed. Pickup and delivery orders run through the restaurant’s website, or call 973-300-0605.

Spring Diner

Booths inside Spring Diner on Spring Street in Newton, NJ
Photo: Spring Diner via Google Business Profile.

Spring Diner at 221 Spring Street is Newton’s breakfast and lunch stop, open seven days a week. Hours are Monday through Thursday 7 a.m. to 3 p.m., Friday and Saturday 7 a.m. to 9 p.m. and Sunday 7 a.m. to 3 p.m. Call 973-579-1711 or order online through the diner’s website.

Dominick’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Dining room at Dominick's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Newton, NJ
Photo: Dominick’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria.

Dominick’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria at 10 East Clinton Street calls itself the first and oldest pizza restaurant in Newton, and the same family has run it since 1984. In 2025, Food Network picked Dominick’s as New Jersey’s best slice, praising its Brooklyn pizza and the Palermo square pie with marinara, red onions and herbs. It is BYOB, with a gluten free menu and online ordering. Hours are Sunday through Thursday 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. and Friday and Saturday 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Call 973-383-9330.

Curd & Cleaver

Storefront of Curd & Cleaver at 7 Moran Street in downtown Newton, NJ
Photo: Curd & Cleaver.

Curd & Cleaver at 7 Moran Street is a cheese, charcuterie and sandwich shop run as an extension of The Farmer’s Daughter, just off Spring Street. The lunch menu includes cheese and meat flights, burrata du jour and sandwiches like the Curd’s Signature with prosciutto, fig jam, burrata, arugula and hot honey on Romano focaccia. Charcuterie boards and Brook Hollow wine are also available. Hours are Tuesday through Saturday 11 a.m. to 4 p.m., with the kitchen closing at 3:30 p.m. Call 973-579-2873.

Raíces Colombianas

Grilled Colombian chorizo with potatoes and salad at Raices Colombianas in Newton, NJ
Photo: Raíces Colombianas.

Raíces Colombianas at 144 Spring Street is one of downtown Newton’s newest kitchens, serving traditional Colombian family recipes for breakfast, lunch and dinner. The menu runs from arepas, empanadas and bandeja paisa to cazuela de mariscos, grilled skirt steak and shareable picada platters, plus a bakery case with pan de bono and buñuelos and fresh juices. Its Google Business Profile lists hours of 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. daily. Call 862-275-7190 for takeout.

La Casa de Campo Restaurant

Grilled steak with mashed potatoes and broccoli at La Casa de Campo Restaurant in Newton, NJ
Photo: La Casa de Campo Restaurant.

La Casa de Campo Restaurant at 11 Main Street is a newer downtown spot serving American and Spanish food from morning until late. Popular items on its ordering page include sopa de res, spaghetti with clams and a mixed burrito filled with chicken, pork and beef. Hours are Monday through Saturday 9 a.m. to 11 p.m. and Sunday 10 a.m. to 11 p.m., which makes it one of the later kitchens in town. Pickup and delivery orders run through the restaurant’s website, or call 862-378-2530.

Sheridan’s Restaurant & Tavern

Covered patio overlooking the lake at Sheridan's Restaurant & Tavern in Newton, NJ
Photo: Sheridan’s Restaurant & Tavern.

Sheridan’s Restaurant & Tavern at 631 Limecrest Road dates to 1978, when Tom and Betty Sheridan opened it, and it is a short drive from downtown with lakefront views and a patio. Expect daily lunch and dinner specials, seasonal cocktails, craft beer on tap, NFL Sunday game specials and a local band every Saturday night. Hours are Sunday through Thursday 11:30 a.m. to midnight and Friday and Saturday 11:30 a.m. to 1 a.m. Call 973-383-7577, or order pickup online through the tavern’s website.

Hampton Diner

Booths in the dining room at Hampton Diner in Newton, NJ
Photo: Hampton Diner.

Hampton Diner at 36 Hampton House Road has served the Newton area since 1993 and keeps an all-day menu going from breakfast through dinner. The diner suggests its pork roll, egg and cheese, and the menu also covers dinner specials, smoothies, crazy shakes and cocktails. A private room with its own bar hosts groups of up to 100. Hours are Monday through Saturday 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. and Sunday 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Call 973-383-1550 or order online through the diner’s website.

Blue Heron Tavern

Dining room at Blue Heron Tavern at North Shore House overlooking Swartswood Lake
Photo: North Shore House.

Blue Heron Tavern at 912 Swartswood Road is the restaurant inside North Shore House, a family owned lakeside inn and event venue, with sweeping views of Swartswood Lake. The dining room and bar have an upscale lake house feel, and the rotating menu leans on fresh, in-season dishes, with weekly specials posted on its website. The tavern is open by reservation only on Friday and Saturday from 5 to 9 p.m., and hours can shift around private events. Book through Resy or call 973-383-5460.

How to Plan a Newton Food Stop

Start early at Spring Diner, which opens at 7 a.m. every day, or book Sunday brunch at The Farmer’s Daughter. Hampton Diner serves until 9 p.m. most nights for a later diner meal. For lunch, Curd & Cleaver makes sandwiches and boards Tuesday through Saturday until 4 p.m. For dinner, Mi Rancho, Indian Masala, Poy’s Kitchen and Raices Colombianas cover Mexican, Indian, Thai Lao and Colombian food, and Dominick’s has been the family pizza pick since 1984. When the rest of Spring Street winds down, O’Reilly’s keeps the kitchen going until midnight. For a meal by the water, Sheridan’s has a lakefront patio, and Blue Heron Tavern serves Friday and Saturday by reservation. Plan around Tuesdays: The Farmer’s Daughter, Indian Masala and Mi Rancho are all closed that day.

Downtown on a Friday morning? The Arbor Bakeshop at the SCCC Culinary Institute serves student-made pastries at 47 Main Street.

Heading to a show? Our Newton Theatre November 2026 lineup lists every concert and showtime on Spring Street.

More Sussex County Restaurant Guides

Eating your way around the county? Start with our town-by-town map of the best restaurants in Sussex County, NJ, or jump straight to a town:

Planning more than a meal? See our guide to things to do in Newton, NJ, stop by Arbor Bakeshop, or browse our Eat & Drink and things to do hubs.

Featured photo: brunch at The Farmer’s Daughter, Newton. Photo credit: The Farmer’s Daughter via Google Business Profile.

Have a Sussex County event coming up?

Share it with Sussex County.

Festivals, fundraisers, 5Ks, school nights, grand openings. Send us the date, time, place and a flyer, and our team will reach out about getting it in front of Sussex County.

Share your event

Enjoying our Sussex County coverage?

Add us as a preferred source and our stories show up higher in your Google results.

Add as a preferred source
Share
Supreme Office Cleaning: office and commercial cleaning in Morris County, NJ. Request a free estimate.
Pawfect Journey: the 13 best automatic litter boxes of 2026
The Hype Hero: your business needs a website. Contact us today.
Shop Sussex County

Get Sussex County in your inbox

Weekend events, new openings, fall fun and hidden gems from all 24 Sussex County towns. Free, every week.

Subscribe free

Instagram  |  Facebook

Related Articles
High Point Monument above the forest with the headline 10 Hikes You Can Do All Year in Sussex County
Things To Do

Hiking Trails in Sussex County NJ: 10 Year-Round Hikes to Try

Ten year-round hiking trails across Sussex County, from High Point's Monument Trail...

Historic brick building on a small town main street with the headline Things to Do in Sussex, NJ
Things To Do

Things to Do in Sussex NJ: Main Street, Deckertown History and More

Our guide to Sussex Borough: Main Street, Deckertown history, the historical society...

Where to See Hawks, Eagles & Warblers in Sussex County
Things To Do

Birding in Sussex County NJ: 4 Places to See Hawks, Eagles and Warblers

Birding in Sussex County, NJ is good all year, from hawks streaming...

Stone Gothic exterior of Christ Episcopal Church on Main Street in Newton, NJ
EventsThings To Do

Free Violin and Piano Recital at Christ Church in Newton, NJ

Christ Episcopal Church in Newton hosts a free violin and piano recital...

SCCC Named One of TIME's Best Community Colleges
Community

Sussex County Community College Named One of TIME’s Best Community Colleges

Sussex County Community College (SCCC) in Newton has been named one of...

Salon Frei storefront in Sparta with the headline 9 Local Hair Salons to Try in Sussex County
Shopping

Hair Salons in Sussex County NJ: 9 Local Salons to Try

Hair salons in Sussex County, NJ stretch from Sparta and Newton to...

Bar taps at a Sussex County NJ pub with the headline 6 Pubs and Taverns for Live Music in Sussex County
Eat & Drink

Bars in Sussex County NJ: 6 Pubs and Taverns for Live Music and More

Six Sussex County bars, pubs and taverns, from Saturday night bands at...

Things to Do in Augusta & Frankford, NJ
Things To Do

Things to Do in Augusta NJ and Frankford: Fairgrounds, Skylands and More

Our guide to Augusta and Frankford Township, from the German Christmas Market...