Best Pizza in Sussex County NJ: 7 Local Pizzerias Across 7 Towns

Finding the best pizza in Sussex County NJ means driving a little, because the good pies are spread across the whole county, from Route 23 in the north to Main Street in Andover and Spring Street in Newton. Our team pulled together seven local pizzerias in seven different towns, each one currently taking orders, so you can find a solid slice wherever you are in the Skylands.

Below you will find the address, phone number and the crust styles and specialty pies each shop lists on its current online menu. We skipped the pizza spots we already covered in our town restaurant guides, so this list doubles as a second round of picks for locals who think they have tried them all.

How we picked these pizzerias

Every pizzeria here is open and taking orders as of fall 2026 on its official online ordering page. We confirmed each address and town, and we only describe pies and crusts that appear on each shop’s own menu. We did not invent ratings or rankings, so the list runs roughly north to south rather than first to last. Menus, hours and delivery areas change, so call ahead before you make a special trip.

7 pizzerias worth the drive in Sussex County

1. Frank’s Pizza and Restaurant, Sussex

Frank’s Pizza and Restaurant sits at 205 Route 23 with a Sussex mailing address, a handy stop if you are heading toward High Point. The menu has a full Sicilian and pan pizza section, including Frank’s Special Sicilian, a white Sicilian and a white broccoli garlic Sicilian, plus a grandma pie with a square thin crust and a personal gluten free cheese pizza. Phone: 973-875-1250.

2. Tony’s Restaurant Pizza and Pub, Stockholm (Hardyston)

Not to be confused with Tony’s Pizza and Pasta in Hamburg, Tony’s Restaurant Pizza and Pub is at 2771 Route 23 in the Stockholm section of Hardyston Township. The menu lists Sicilian cheese pizza, gluten free pizza and a cauliflower crust pizza. When we checked, the online ordering page was taking pickup orders only, so plan to grab your pie at the counter. Phone: 973-545-7712.

3. Franklin Dominick’s, Franklin

Franklin Dominick’s is at 190 Munsonhurst Road in Franklin. The shop calls its Palermo pizza its signature pie: a square crust topped with red onions, fresh basil, olive oil, marinara and mozzarella. The Drunken Nonna is another square pie, with fresh mozzarella, marinara, vodka sauce and basil. The menu also lists a very thin Brooklyn pizza baked with fresh garlic and crushed red pepper, and a gluten free crust pizza. Phone: 973-545-7230. Make a day of it with our guide to things to do in Franklin.

4. Casa Mia, Sparta (Lake Mohawk)

Casa Mia is at 20 White Deer Plaza, right in the Lake Mohawk business district in Sparta. The menu offers a wide range of crusts, including traditional, artisan, stuffed, gluten free and cauliflower, plus super thin and square thin artisan options on some pies. Look for the Uncle Vic, an artisan crust topped with pepperoni, sausage, bacon and ham. Phone: 973-729-6606.

5. Paco’s Pizzeria and Restaurant, Newton

Paco’s Pizzeria and Restaurant is at 220 Spring Street in downtown Newton. The menu has a little of everything: Sicilian, deep dish, grandma, bar style, stuffed and thin crust Brooklyn and Palermo pies, plus a gluten free cheese pizza. Early risers should note the breakfast pizzas: a Taylor ham, bacon, egg and cheese pie, a sausage, egg and cheese pie and a western omelette pizza. Phone: 973-579-1480.

6. AG Pizza and Restaurant, Branchville

AG Pizza and Restaurant is at 3 Mill Street in Branchville borough. The specialty list leans creative, with chicken parm pizza, chicken marsala pizza, eggplant rollatini pizza, loaded potato pizza, cheesesteak pizza and a Drunken Grandma pie, along with grandma, Brooklyn and Palermo pies. It is an easy stop on the way to or from Stokes State Forest. Phone: 973-948-2875.

7. Vinny and Son Pizza, Andover

Vinny and Son Pizza is at 184 Main Street in Andover borough, along Route 206. Crust options include regular, deep dish, gluten free and cauliflower, and the menu also lists square Sicilian and grandma pies. Look for the arugula chicken pizza, with grilled chicken, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, arugula and honey balsamic, plus a Drunk Grandma pie and a chicken Torrente pie with breaded chicken, vodka sauce and fresh mozzarella. Phone: 973-786-4136.

More pizza from our town guides

Several of the county’s best known pizza spots already appear in our town restaurant roundups, and they are well worth a visit too:

• Hopatcong: The Grotto Restaurant, a Sicilian style pizza and pasta spot, in our guide to where to eat in Hopatcong.
• Hamburg: Nonna Vita Trattoria, Pomodoro Italiano and Tony’s Pizza and Pasta in our roundup of the best restaurants in Hamburg.
• Vernon: Tomato Garden Pizza and Restaurant in our best restaurants in Vernon guide.
• Stanhope: Carlo’s Cucina Italiana in our list of the best restaurants in Stanhope.
• Sparta: Casa Bellisima and its wood fired pizza in our guide to where to eat and drink in Sparta.

Know before you go

• Call ahead. Hours, delivery zones and pickup only periods change by season. Every shop above lists its phone number, so a quick call saves a wasted trip.
• Know your style. Around here, grandma pies are square with a thin crust, Sicilian means a thick square, and Palermo is another square style. Brooklyn style is a very thin pie.
• Gluten free options. Frank’s, Tony’s, Casa Mia, Franklin Dominick’s, Paco’s and Vinny and Son all list gluten free pizza on their menus. If you have celiac disease, ask each kitchen about how they prevent cross contact.
• Mailing addresses. Many Sussex County businesses use a post office name that differs from the municipality, so plug the street address into your map app rather than the town name.
• Pair it with a pint. Several of these shops are a short drive from a taproom on our list of breweries in Sussex County.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can I get Sicilian pizza in Sussex County NJ?

Frank’s Pizza in Sussex, Tony’s Restaurant Pizza and Pub in Stockholm, Franklin Dominick’s in Franklin, Casa Mia in Sparta, Paco’s in Newton, AG Pizza in Branchville and Vinny and Son in Andover all list Sicilian or square pies on their menus.

Which Sussex County pizzerias offer gluten free pizza?

Frank’s, Tony’s, Casa Mia, Franklin Dominick’s, Paco’s and Vinny and Son all list gluten free crust. Casa Mia, Tony’s and Vinny and Son also list a cauliflower crust.

Is there pizza near Lake Mohawk?

Yes. Casa Mia is at 20 White Deer Plaza in Sparta, steps from the Lake Mohawk boardwalk area.

Can I get breakfast pizza in Sussex County?

Paco’s Pizzeria in Newton lists breakfast pizzas on its menu, including a Taylor ham, egg and cheese pie.

Do these pizzerias deliver?

Most of them offer delivery or pickup through their online ordering pages, but delivery areas and fees vary. Tony’s in Stockholm was listing pickup only when we checked, so call the shop to confirm.

Hungry for more local picks? Our free Shop Sussex County newsletter rounds up the best food, events and things to do across all 24 towns every week. Sign up free here.

Primary sources for this guide: Frank’s Pizza and Restaurant menu, Tony’s Restaurant Pizza and Pub menu, Franklin Dominick’s menu, Casa Mia menu, Paco’s Pizzeria menu, AG Pizza and Restaurant Branchville menu and Vinny and Son Pizza menu.

Featured photo: stock image of a pizza, for illustration only. Photo by Horizon Content via Pexels.