Never miss what is happening in Sussex County
Events, new openings and weekend plans from Newton to Vernon, Sparta to Stanhope. Straight to your inbox, free.
The best bakeries in Sussex County NJ include a Dutch bakery that has been baking since 1954, a French patisserie with two locations, a student run bakeshop in Newton and a farm bakery known for apple cider donuts. Our team rounded up six bakeries in six towns, so wherever you live in the Skylands, fresh pastries are not far away.
With Thanksgiving on Thursday, Nov. 26, 2026 and the holiday season right behind it, now is the time to plan your pie, cake and cookie orders. Below you will find addresses, hours where posted, and what each bakery lists on its own site.
How we picked these bakeries
Every bakery here has a current website or an active official listing in 2026, and we only describe items and hours they publish. We did not invent ratings or rankings, and we tell you where hours were not posted so you can call before you go.
6 bakeries worth the drive in Sussex County
1. Holland American Bakery, Wantage
Holland American Bakery at 246 Route 23 in Wantage has been serving rural northern New Jersey since 1954 and specializes in traditional Dutch treats. Its website lists speculaas cookies, banket almond rings, krakelingen, almond stollen, jan hagel cookies, stroopwafels, almond tarts, gevulde koeken, linzer tarts and boterkoek, plus Dutch cheeses such as aged gouda, licorice, peppermints and imported pantry items. Gluten free baked goods, gift boxes and holiday specialties are on the menu too, and the bakery ships nationwide. Per its contact page, the store is open Tuesday through Saturday 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. and closed Sunday and Monday. Phone: 973-875-5258.
2. Cafe Pierrot, Andover and Sparta
Cafe Pierrot is a French bakery with a bakery shop at 212 Main Street in Andover borough and a cafe at 19 Sparta Avenue in Sparta. The bakery menu covers pastries, breads, custom cakes, cupcakes, cookies, macarons and wedding cakes. Per its website, the Andover bakery is open Monday through Saturday 7 a.m. to 4 p.m., and the Sparta cafe is open Monday 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. and Tuesday through Saturday 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Both are closed Sunday. Phone: Andover 973-786-6069, Sparta 973-729-0988.
3. Arbor Bakeshop, Newton
The Arbor Bakeshop is run by Baking and Pastry Arts students at the Culinary Institute of Sussex County Community College, 47 Main Street in Newton. Per the college, it opens Fridays from 8:30 to 10:30 a.m., with croissants, pain au chocolat, almond croissants, kouign amann, a gluten free eclair du jour and canneles, weekly specials such as quiche, scones, donuts and muffins, plus espresso drinks and tea. Preorders are taken online through the college’s Tock page. Because it is a student program, check the college site for open dates around school breaks. Get the full story in our Arbor Bakeshop guide.
4. Pattycakes, Sparta
Pattycakes is a custom cake and dessert shop at 20 White Deer Plaza in the Lake Mohawk section of Sparta. It makes custom cakes, cupcakes, cookies, cake pops, dessert tables and custom treat boxes, and the coffee menu includes matcha and fresh coffee. Its production kitchen at 5 Aaron Way is open by appointment only. The hours on its website were summer hours, so call 973-862-8827 for current fall and holiday hours.
5. Heaven Hill Farm Market and Bakery, Vernon
Heaven Hill Farm at 451 Route 94 in Vernon runs a farm market and bakery with fresh baked items and apple cider donuts. Per its website, the farm is open 9 a.m. to 6 p.m., seven days a week. The Great Pumpkin Festival wraps up Nov. 8, so by the time you read this the market is your reason to visit. Revisit our Great Pumpkin Festival guide for next fall. Phone: 973-764-5144.
6. Two Teaspoons, Hamburg
Two Teaspoons at 2 Main Street in Hamburg focuses on bespoke wedding and celebration cakes, with cake tastings, cupcakes and groom’s cakes. Its listing notes dairy free, gluten free, vegan and vegetarian options and rotating seasonal flavors. This is an order ahead bakery, so reach out before you visit. Planning dinner nearby? See our roundup of the best restaurants in Hamburg.
Holiday baking: what to order where
November and December are peak season for local bakers, so here is how our list lines up with the holidays:
- Thanksgiving desserts and breads: Cafe Pierrot lists pastries, breads and custom cakes at its Andover bakery, which opens at 7 a.m. Monday through Saturday.
- Christmas cookies and Dutch classics: Holland American Bakery lists holiday specialties along with speculaas, almond stollen and banket. Because it ships nationwide, it also works for gifts to family out of state.
- Party cakes and dessert tables: Pattycakes builds custom cakes, cupcakes, cake pops and full dessert tables for holiday parties.
- Celebration and wedding cakes: Two Teaspoons and Cafe Pierrot both make wedding cakes, and Two Teaspoons offers tastings.
- Something small and special: The Arbor Bakeshop’s Friday morning pastries, from croissants to canneles, make an easy weekend treat when classes are in session.
Bakeries by town at a glance
- Wantage: Holland American Bakery on Route 23.
- Andover: Cafe Pierrot bakery at 212 Main Street.
- Sparta: Cafe Pierrot’s cafe on Sparta Avenue and Pattycakes at White Deer Plaza. More Sparta food picks are in our guide to where to eat and drink in Sparta.
- Newton: Arbor Bakeshop at 47 Main Street.
- Vernon: Heaven Hill Farm Market and Bakery on Route 94.
- Hamburg: Two Teaspoons at 2 Main Street.
Know before you go
- Order holiday treats early. Thanksgiving is Thursday, Nov. 26, 2026. Custom cakes and holiday specialties usually need lead time, so place orders as early as possible.
- Go early. Bakery cases sell down through the day, and the Arbor Bakeshop is only open two hours on Fridays.
- Sunday closures. Both Cafe Pierrot locations and Holland American Bakery are closed on Sunday, and Holland American is also closed Monday.
- Dietary needs. Holland American Bakery lists gluten free baked goods, and Two Teaspoons lists dairy free, gluten free and vegan options. Ask about cross contact if you have an allergy.
- Make it a morning. Pair a pastry with a stop from our list of the best coffee shops in Sussex County.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I buy Dutch pastries in New Jersey?
Holland American Bakery on Route 23 in Wantage has served the area since 1954 with Dutch baked goods, including speculaas, stroopwafels, banket and boterkoek, and it ships nationwide.
Where can I order a custom cake in Sussex County NJ?
Cafe Pierrot, Pattycakes and Two Teaspoons all list custom cakes, and Cafe Pierrot and Two Teaspoons both make wedding cakes.
When is the Arbor Bakeshop open?
The student run bakeshop in Newton is open Fridays from 8:30 to 10:30 a.m., per the college. Check the college site for dates around school breaks.
Where can I get apple cider donuts in Sussex County?
Heaven Hill Farm in Vernon lists apple cider donuts at its farm market and bakery, open 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. daily.
Are there gluten free bakeries in Sussex County?
Holland American Bakery offers gluten free baked goods, and Two Teaspoons lists gluten free cake options. Call ahead to confirm availability.
Never miss a local find. Our free newsletter rounds up the best food, events and things to do across all 24 Sussex County towns every week. Join free here.
Primary sources for this guide: Holland American Bakery, Cafe Pierrot, Sussex County Community College Arbor Bakeshop, Pattycakes, Heaven Hill Farm and Two Teaspoons on The Knot.
Featured photo: stock image of a bakery case, for illustration only. Photo by James Collington via Pexels.
Have a Sussex County event coming up?
Share it with Sussex County.
Festivals, fundraisers, 5Ks, school nights, grand openings. Send us the date, time, place and a flyer, and our team will reach out about getting it in front of Sussex County.
Enjoying our Sussex County coverage?
Add us as a preferred source and our stories show up higher in your Google results.
Add as a preferred source



