Thanksgiving Pies in Sussex County NJ: Farms and Bakeries Taking Orders

The best places to order Thanksgiving pies in Sussex County NJ this year are Windy Brow Farms in Fredon, Pochuck Valley Farms in Glenwood, Clove Brook Market in Wantage and Heaven Hill Farm in Vernon, with Green Life Market and Sparta Classic Diner also taking holiday orders. Most order deadlines fall between November 19 and November 22, 2026, so our team recommends getting your order in this week or next.

Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26, 2026. We checked every farm, bakery and market below on its own website, including pie flavors, prices where posted, order deadlines and pickup days. Where a business has not posted 2026 Thanksgiving details, we say so.

At a Glance

• Windy Brow Farms, Fredon: online pre-orders open until November 21, pickup November 24 or 25
• Pochuck Valley Farms, Glenwood: $29 pies, orders taken November 1 to 19, pickup November 23 to 25
• Clove Brook Market, Wantage: 9-inch pies from $18.95, order by Friday, November 20
• Heaven Hill Farm, Vernon: farm market open daily 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. with fresh pies
• Green Life Market, Andover and Vernon: gluten-free apple crumb and gluten-free vegan pumpkin pies, order by November 20
• Sparta Classic Diner, Sparta: whole pumpkin and apple pies, order by Sunday, November 22
• Hainesville General Store, Sandyston: award-winning fruit pies, 48 hours notice for special orders

Farms Taking Thanksgiving Pie Orders

1. Windy Brow Farms

Windy Brow is a family farm in Fredon Township, and its farm shop is a fall favorite for cider and baked goods. The farm has opened Thanksgiving 2026 pre-orders online. This year’s list includes Apple Crust, Apple Crumb, Very Berry Crumb, Blueberry Crumb, Blueberry Crust, Caramel Apple Crumb, Apple Raspberry Crumb, Apple Cranberry Crumb and Pumpkin. The farm bakes pies fresh Thursday through Sunday and sells frozen pies on other days.

• Address: 359 Ridge Road, Newton (Fredon Township)
• Hours: Farm shop Monday to Wednesday 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., Thursday to Sunday 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. (fall hours)
• Thanksgiving orders: Pre-orders open until November 21; pickup Tuesday, November 24 or Wednesday, November 25, 10 a.m. to 5:45 p.m.
• Good to know: Choose your pickup slot when you order, since the system defaults to the soonest one. No refunds after the cancellation deadline.
• Phone: (973) 579-9657
• Website: Windy Brow Farms Thanksgiving pre-orders

2. Pochuck Valley Farms Market and Deli (Diana’s Bakery)

Pochuck Valley Farms has one of the longest pie lists in the county. Diana’s Bakery makes Apple, Apple Crumb, Pumpkin, Cherry, Blueberry, Berry, Lemon Meringue, Coconut Custard, Coconut Cream, Banana Cream, Chocolate Cream, Mincemeat, Fruits of the Forest, Pecan and Strawberry Rhubarb, with crumb versions of several fruit pies. Every pie is $29, and you can take it home frozen or baked. Sugar-free and gluten-free pies are available by special order.

• Address: 962 McAfee-Glenwood Road, Glenwood (Vernon Township)
• Hours: Monday to Friday 6 a.m. to 5 p.m., Saturday and Sunday 6 a.m. to 3 p.m.; closed Thanksgiving Day
• Cost: $29 per pie
• Thanksgiving orders: All pies must be pre-ordered. Orders are taken November 1 to 19, with pickup Monday, November 23 to Wednesday, November 25.
• Phone: 973-764-4732
• Website: Diana’s Bakery at Pochuck Valley Farms

3. Heaven Hill Farm

Heaven Hill Farm on Route 94 is best known for its fall festival, but the farm market bakery is a good stop for a last-minute pie. Its pie list includes Apple, Caramel Apple Walnut, Dutch Apple, seasonal Pumpkin, Blueberry, Coconut Custard, Cherry, Very Berry and Strawberry Rhubarb, plus No Sugar Blueberry and No Sugar Apple. Grab cider donuts while you are there. The farm had not posted a 2026 Thanksgiving pre-order form when we checked, so call ahead if you want a specific flavor held.

• Address: 451 State Route 94, Vernon
• Hours: Farm market open daily 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
• Thanksgiving orders: No 2026 pre-order details posted; call to ask
• Phone: (973) 764-5144
• Website: Heaven Hill Farm Market

Bakeries and Markets Taking Pie Orders

4. Clove Brook Market

Clove Brook Market is a bakery, deli and caterer on Route 23 in Wantage with a big fruit and cream pie menu. Fruit pies include Traditional Apple, Dutch Apple Crumb, Apple Berry Smash, Caramel Apple Pecan, Swedish Apple Walnut, Cherry, Blueberry Crust, Cherry Raspberry, Pumpkin, Pumpkin Pecan and a Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie. Cream pies include Banana, Coconut, Key Lime, Chocolate and Raspberry.

• Address: 800 NJ-23, Wantage (Sussex mailing address)
• Hours: Monday to Friday 5:30 a.m. to 6 p.m., Saturday 7 a.m. to 4 p.m., closed Sunday
• Cost: Fruit pies $18.95 (9-inch) or $7.95 (6-inch); Pecan $25 (9-inch); cream pies $20.95 (9-inch)
• Thanksgiving orders: Order by Friday, November 20, by phone or in person. The market does not take orders by email.
• Phone: (973) 875-5600
• Website: Clove Brook Market Holidays

5. Green Life Market

Green Life Market is an organic, health-focused grocery, and it is the place to go if someone at your table eats gluten-free or vegan. Its 2026 Holiday Menu includes an Apple Crumb Pie with a gluten-free crust and a gluten-free, vegan Pumpkin Pie, plus a Pumpkin Cheesecake. Green Life has two Sussex County stores, in Andover and Vernon.

• Address: 238 Newton Sparta Road, Andover, and 265 NJ-94, Vernon
• Hours: Store hours vary by location; check the website
• Cost: Gluten-free Apple Crumb Pie $28.99; gluten-free vegan Pumpkin Pie $26.99; Pumpkin Cheesecake $29.99
• Thanksgiving orders: Order by Friday, November 20, in store with the paper form or by phone with a credit card. All orders are prepaid. Pickup Tuesday, November 24 or Wednesday, November 25 during store hours.
• Phone: Andover 973-512-3900, Vernon 973-209-8555
• Website: Green Life Market Thanksgiving menu

6. Sparta Classic Diner

Sparta Classic Diner sells whole pies on its 2026 Thanksgiving catering menu, which is handy if you are already ordering sides or a full dinner. Its Thanksgiving dinner packages for one, four or a group of 10 to 12 include pumpkin or apple pie.

• Address: 80 Woodport Road, Sparta
• Hours: Sunday to Thursday 8 a.m. to 9 p.m., Friday and Saturday 8 a.m. to 10 p.m.
• Cost: Whole Pumpkin Pie $32, whole Apple Pie $28
• Thanksgiving orders: Call to order by Sunday, November 22; pickup by 1 p.m. on Thanksgiving Day
• Phone: (973) 729-2425
• Website: Sparta Classic Diner Thanksgiving 2026

7. Hainesville General Store

Up near Stokes State Forest, Hainesville General Store bakes fruit pies with crumb or double crusts. The store says its pies took the first place blue ribbon at the New Jersey State Fair six years in a row. It had not posted a 2026 Thanksgiving menu when we checked, but it takes special orders with 48 hours notice, so call ahead.

• Address: 283 US 206, Sandyston
• Hours: Monday to Saturday 6 a.m. to 2 p.m., Sunday 7 a.m. to 2 p.m.
• Thanksgiving orders: No 2026 Thanksgiving details posted; allow 48 hours for special orders
• Phone: 973-948-4280
• Website: Hainesville General Store Bakery

Tips for Ordering Thanksgiving Pies

Order early. The deadlines are close together this year: Pochuck Valley stops taking orders November 19, Clove Brook and Green Life on November 20, Windy Brow on November 21 and Sparta Classic Diner on November 22. Popular flavors like pumpkin and apple crumb go first.

Plan your pickup day. Most farm pickups are Monday, November 23 through Wednesday, November 25. Pochuck Valley is closed on Thanksgiving Day, so do not plan a Thursday morning run. If you want a pie on the day itself, Sparta Classic Diner offers pickup until 1 p.m. on Thanksgiving.

Know how each place takes orders. Windy Brow takes orders online, Clove Brook and Pochuck Valley take phone or in-person orders, and Green Life requires prepayment. Have your flavor list and a backup pick ready when you call.

Make it a farm stop. Several of these farms sell cider, donuts and produce too. See our list of farm stands still open in November in Sussex County to plan a route.

More for Your Sussex County Thanksgiving

Hosting this year or heading out? Our Thanksgiving in Sussex County guide covers dinners and turkey trots. The weekend after, shop local with our Small Business Saturday in Sussex County guide and our favorite gift shops in Sussex County. Want to give back? Here is where to find toy drives in Sussex County, and our Christmas events in Sussex County calendar is ready for December.

FAQ

Where can I order Thanksgiving pies in Sussex County NJ?

Windy Brow Farms in Fredon, Pochuck Valley Farms in Glenwood, Clove Brook Market in Wantage, Green Life Market in Andover and Vernon, and Sparta Classic Diner all list Thanksgiving pie ordering. Heaven Hill Farm in Vernon and Hainesville General Store in Sandyston also sell pies.

When is the deadline to order Thanksgiving pies?

For 2026, Pochuck Valley takes orders through November 19, Clove Brook and Green Life through Friday, November 20, Windy Brow through November 21 and Sparta Classic Diner through Sunday, November 22.

Can I get a gluten-free Thanksgiving pie in Sussex County?

Yes. Green Life Market offers a gluten-free Apple Crumb Pie and a gluten-free, vegan Pumpkin Pie, and Pochuck Valley Farms makes sugar-free and gluten-free pies by special order.

How much do Thanksgiving pies cost?

Posted prices range from $18.95 for a 9-inch fruit pie at Clove Brook Market to $29 at Pochuck Valley Farms and $32 for a whole pumpkin pie at Sparta Classic Diner.

Can I pick up a pie on Thanksgiving Day?

Sparta Classic Diner offers pickup until 1 p.m. on Thanksgiving Day. Most farm pickups run November 23 to 25, and Pochuck Valley is closed on Thanksgiving.

Which farm has the most pie flavors?

Pochuck Valley Farms lists 15 pies, from apple and pumpkin to mincemeat, coconut cream and strawberry rhubarb, all at $29 each.