Never miss what is happening in Sussex County
Events, new openings and weekend plans from Newton to Vernon, Sparta to Stanhope. Straight to your inbox, free.
Looking for things to do in Stillwater NJ? Our team rounded up the best of this quiet western Sussex County township: lakeside trails at Swartswood State Park, a historic gristmill and museum, a busy township park, the Fairview Lake YMCA camp and the fall festival that brings the whole town out each October.
Stillwater Township sits about eight miles west of Newton, according to the township’s official website, and was incorporated on December 27, 1824. Most of what visitors come for here is outdoors, historic or both. Below is where to go, what each place offers and what to know before you head out.
Swartswood State Park
Swartswood State Park is the township’s biggest draw, and the township lists it first among its parks and lakes. For fees, camping, boat rentals and the full rundown on Swartswood Lake, see our complete Swartswood State Park guide. Here is a quick look at the four trails the township’s hiking and trails page describes inside the park.
Duck Pond Multi-Use Trail
A 0.6 mile paved path with a level surface for walking, biking and skating. The township notes it is accessible for people with disabilities, and it has wayside exhibits and a bird blind. This is the easiest outing in Stillwater and a good pick with a stroller.
Spring Lake Trail
This 2.8 mile trail starts where the paved Duck Pond Trail ends and follows white markers to secluded Spring Lake. The township rates it a moderate hike.
Bear Claw Trail
A 0.8 mile yellow trail that begins at the Duck Pond parking area on an earthen, hilly path rated easy to moderate. It meets the Duck Pond Trail, so you can combine the two into a short loop back to your car.
Grist Mill Trail
The most challenging of the four: a 1.5 mile loop at the southern end of Swartswood Lake by the dam, with steep, rocky terrain rated moderate to difficult. The payoff is the view of Swartswood Lake. The township links an official park map you can download before you go.
Stillwater Historic Sites
Stillwater has kept more of its 19th century character than most Sussex County towns, and the Historical Society of Stillwater Township is the place to start if you want the stories behind it.
Casper and Abraham Shafer Mill Complex
The Shafer gristmill was built in 1844 on the ruins of a 1764 grist mill. Per the historical society, it was one of the last water-powered mills in New Jersey when it stopped operating in 1954. The complex was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2009, and the society placed a plaque there in 2015. The society has launched a “Save the Gristmill” campaign, starting with engineering blueprints for replacing the deteriorating roof, so the mill is a site to appreciate from the outside unless a guided tour is scheduled.
Historical Society Headquarters and Museum
The society’s headquarters is at 900 Main Street in Stillwater, with parking at the Presbyterian Church across the street. The society maintains a historical and genealogical library and museum, and lists visiting hours of June through October, Sundays from 2 to 4 p.m., or by appointment. Its genealogist has digitized articles on about 2,000 Sussex County families organized by surname, which makes it a useful stop if you are tracing local roots. The society also runs the Voices of Stillwater oral history project, built from interviews with longtime residents.
Stillwater Fall Festival
Every October the historical society hosts the Stillwater Fall Festival, and the organizer billed 2026 as its 20th annual festival. This year’s festival took place on Saturday, October 10 at Stillwater Elementary School, kicking off with a tractor parade, and the society used it to launch its Save the Gristmill campaign. Members and supporters got a free tour of the Shafer Gristmill led by town historian Andy Martin, and the museum opened extra hours that weekend. Watch the historical society’s website next fall for the 2027 date. The society took part in the countywide art and heritage weekend, which we covered in our Sussex County Heritage Weekend guide.
Stillwater Park
For a ball game, a picnic or a playground stop, the township’s Stillwater Park at 931 Swartswood Road is open dawn to dusk. Per the township, it has a tennis and pickleball court, a baseball field with an electronic scoreboard, a concession stand and batting cage, a playground, a basketball court and picnic tables. The township also lists Veteran’s Memorial Park and Volunteer Field among its parks; check the parks page for details on those.
Fairview Lake YMCA Camps
Fairview Lake YMCA Camps, at 1035 Fairview Lake Road (Newton mailing address), has been operating since 1915 and sits on 660 acres, according to the camp’s website. It is best known for summer sleepaway and day camps, but it runs year-round programs too: family and parent-child weekends, adult programs, conference and retreat groups, school trips, scout camporees and cross-country skiing. The camp also opens its gates for community events. This fall it hosted its Pig Roast and Community Harvest Day on October 4, and its community events page lists Fairview Fest, a free holiday market with local vendors, on Saturday, November 28, 2026 from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. Check the camp’s site for what else is coming up.
Lakes Around Stillwater
Beyond Swartswood, the township’s lakes page lists Paulinskill Lake, Lake Plymouth and Crandon Lakes. Access rules differ from lake to lake, so check the township’s page for each one before you plan to launch a boat or fish. For public lakes where you can swim and paddle across the county, see our guide to lakes in Sussex County NJ.
A Day in Stillwater: Sample Plan
- Morning: Walk the Duck Pond Trail and Bear Claw Trail loop at Swartswood State Park, or tackle the Grist Mill Trail if you want a workout.
- Midday: Head to the historical society headquarters at 900 Main Street. In season, time it for the museum’s Sunday afternoon hours.
- Afternoon: Let the kids burn off energy at Stillwater Park, then drive about eight miles east to Newton for dinner. Our Newton restaurant guide has plenty of options.
Know Before You Go
- Addresses: Many Stillwater properties, including Town Hall and Stillwater Park, use a Newton mailing address (07860), while the historical society uses Stillwater (07875). Plug the street address into your GPS rather than the town name.
- Seasonal hours: The historical society museum lists hours of June through October only, so plan an off-season visit by appointment. State park facilities and fees change by season; confirm on the official park page before you go.
- Trail conditions: The Grist Mill Trail is steep and rocky. Wear real hiking shoes, and expect mud or ice in late fall and winter.
- Township contact: Stillwater Township’s municipal building is at 964 Stillwater Road, Newton, open Monday through Friday from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m., phone 973-383-9484.
- Nearby: Newton, Fredon and Hampton are all short drives away. Our things to do in Newton NJ guide covers the county seat.
Never miss a Sussex County weekend. Our free newsletter rounds up the best events, food and things to do across all 24 towns every week. Sign up free here.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Stillwater NJ known for?
Stillwater is known for Swartswood State Park and Swartswood Lake, the historic Shafer gristmill, the Fairview Lake YMCA camp and its October fall festival hosted by the Historical Society of Stillwater Township.
Is Swartswood State Park in Stillwater?
Yes. Stillwater Township lists Swartswood State Park among its parks, and the township’s own trail guide covers the park’s trails around Swartswood Lake. See our Swartswood State Park guide for fees and camping.
When is the Stillwater Fall Festival?
The festival is held each October. In 2026 it took place on Saturday, October 10 at Stillwater Elementary School. Check the historical society’s website for the 2027 date.
Can you visit the Stillwater gristmill?
The Shafer Mill Complex is on the National Register of Historic Places. The historical society offered a free gristmill tour for members and supporters at its 2026 fall festival; contact the society at info@historicstillwater.org about other visits.
What is the easiest hike in Stillwater?
The Duck Pond Multi-Use Trail at Swartswood State Park is a 0.6 mile paved, level path that the township lists as accessible for people with disabilities.
Primary sources for this guide: Stillwater Township, Stillwater Township hiking and trails, Stillwater Township parks, Historical Society of Stillwater Township and Fairview Lake YMCA Camps.
Featured photo: the Shafer Grist Mill in Stillwater. Photo by Ammodramus via Wikimedia Commons, CC0.
Have a Sussex County event coming up?
Share it with Sussex County.
Festivals, fundraisers, 5Ks, school nights, grand openings. Send us the date, time, place and a flyer, and our team will reach out about getting it in front of Sussex County.
Enjoying our Sussex County coverage?
Add us as a preferred source and our stories show up higher in your Google results.
Add as a preferred source



